Wall
Street industry groups warn that new rules could raise costs and thus
make advice unaffordable to many middle-income Americans. It’s not clear
what the final administration proposal will look like—Labor Secretary
Thomas Perez says it will be “very different” from previous proposals.
But the goal is to end biased advice that the administration estimates
costs investors $17 billion a year.
401(k)-IRA rollovers
For many workers with a 401(k) who are approaching retirement, the best option is to do nothing. Their employers offer 401(k) plans with low fees and great investment choices. There’s no reason to move the money to an individual retirement account, or IRA. But as Bloomberg’s John Hechinger reported last year, investment firms push workers to do just that. For example, federal employees are urged to shift assets into IRAs with fees that are 20 times as high as those in the Federal Thrift Savings Plan.
Load fees
When
customers buy a mutual fund from a broker, they’re still often charged a
front-load fee—a one-time fee that can swallow up more than 5 percent
of their money before it’s invested. The proceeds from load fees help
compensate advisers for their time, though there are often far more
efficient ways to get advice. More and more investors are asking for
no-load mutual funds, but the Investment Company Institute estimates
that $630 billion in load funds were sold in 2013, the latest data
available. That was up 19 percent from 2012 and the most since 2008.
Opaque fees
While
you might notice a 5 percent load fee, many other commissions charged
by advisers are hard to spot. For example, a “12b-1 fee” can be tacked
on to a fund’s expenses every year, with the proceeds often going to an
adviser years after he or she sold the fund. Most of these charges
should be disclosed somewhere, but it can be very difficult for clients
to add up all the various ways an adviser is making money off them.
Active fund bias
In
many investment categories, low-fee index funds have historically
performed better than actively managed mutual funds. But when an adviser
meets a client with lots of assets in index funds, he or she often
urges the client to reallocate into higher-fee funds. When mystery
shoppers visited advisers for a 2012 study, 85 percent were told to ditch their diversified, low-fee portfolios.
Poor performance
Commissions,
including load fees and 12b-1 fees, give advisers an incentive to
recommend certain investment products over others. Firms can also give
advisers bonuses for steering client money into the firms’ own funds.
The result of this biased advice is that investment performance suffers,
academic studies show—and not just because fees eat into returns. A
2014 study
compared self-directed investors with clients who received advice with
conflicts of interest. The self-directed investors performed an average
of 1.25 percentage points better annually. A 2009 study
found that direct-sold funds beat broker-sold funds by 0.14 to 0.9
percentage point per year, even disregarding the broker funds' higher
fees. Over time, that performance gap can cost you thousands, or tens of
thousands, of dollars.
Culled from Bloomberg.com
No comments:
Post a Comment